Thursday, November 7, 2024
HomeTop StoriesIllinois AG sides with Winnetka in Open Meetings Act dispute related to...

Illinois AG sides with Winnetka in Open Meetings Act dispute related to lakefront land controversy

Published on

spot_img


Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul has ruled that the village of Winnetka did not violate the Open Meetings Act during discussions last year about properties owned by billionaire resident Justin Ishbia.

The challenge was filed by Winnetka resident Ted Wynnychenko after the Dec. 6, 2022, Village Council meeting where discussion was held about the consolidation of several plots of land owned by Ishbia and his wife Kristin. After an hour in closed session, the council voted unanimously to approve combining the four lots into a single 3.7-acre lot for the family to build a home.

“Both sides, the property owner and those objecting to the resolution, threatened the village with litigation in open session that night,” Village Attorney Peter Friedman said during the Aug. 1 council meeting in reference to Raoul’s ruling that was made earlier that day. “In an extended closed session, the board engaged in a productive and creative discussion on how to navigate the resolution in order to protect the village from litigation.”

Martin Sinclair, a lawyer for Winnetka resident Rob Schriesheim who had previously filed suit against the Winnetka Park District, spoke at the Dec. 6 meeting and threatened a lawsuit if the village approved the consolidation under the grounds of the Illinois Public Trust Doctrine.

Ishbia’s lawyer, Adam Hoeflich, also threatened suit saying the village must approve the consolidation as the applications are complete and there was no lawful basis to deny them.

Wynnychenko spoke at the Dec. 6 meeting as well, saying he had prepared comments but instead chose to rebut statements made by Hoeflich.

See also  Chicago’s winter parking ban to go into effect Friday

“I have no problem with the consolidation but I am troubled by their attempts to demarcate state land as private land,” Wynnychenko said. “Clearly, this council must approve this because otherwise there is going to be a lawsuit filed saying that you did the wrong thing. I feel that that threat was repeated so often that it was not even subtle.”

Friedman said the complaint alleged the Village Council didn’t have grounds to enter closed session and had strayed from the authorized topics and conducted illegal discussions during closed session. Probable or imminent litigation, such as those threatened against the Village Council twice that evening, is considered an authorized topic to be discussed in closed session, according to the Open Meetings Act.

“Needless to say, it is not everyday that the attorney general reviews closed session recordings and then finds entirely for the local government,” Friedman said. “That the PAC (public access counselor) did so here, while it was as we predicted, speaks volumes to the village’s commitment to complying with the Open Meetings Act even in the context of difficult and sensitive matters that come before the village.”

Village President Chris Rintz assured residents in December there would be continued discussions of the lakefront and how the village can regulate it.

“It’s easy to stand up at the podium and say all sorts of things but as an elected body we really are held to a higher standard than opinions offered in the microphone,” he said on Dec. 6. “We’re going to do the hard work. We’re going to find the right people. We’re going to bring them to the table and we hope that everybody in this room will join us for those conversations.”

See also  Safety Lewis Cine a healthy scratch for first time

The Village Council has gone forward with those conversations as promised where it learned of gaps in state and federal regulations stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic. It also learned village jurisdiction extends into the lake meaning the village can pick up the regulatory slack.

The Village Council approved ordinances to add regulations in March 2023 requiring permits from the village to build on the lakefront in addition to those required by the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District, Illinois Department of Natural Resources, Illinois Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Ishbia’s land, the homes on it and all the trees have since been bulldozed along with the bluff, causing the Village Council to suspend new construction on the bluffs and tableland 40 feet back for nine months while they look into the potential damage bluff construction can cause.

Construction workers and machinery fill the lakefront property of Justin Ishbia along Sheridan Road in Winnetka on July 19, 2023. Since construction started earlier this summer, nearly all of the trees have been cut down and the bluff has been taken down. The property was once four lots and three separate homes.  It is now a 3.7-acre property.

The Dec. 6 meeting is just one of many examples of discontent in the village over Ishbia’s plans with continued discussion surrounding the destruction of the bluffs and removal of all trees on his property immediately south of Centennial Park.

Residents such as Mary Garrison and Vicki Apatoff, who travel along the waterfront, as is allowed by the Illinois Trust Doctrine, have been confronted by security when they reach Ishbia’s property line and told they are trespassing. The doctrine states the land under Lake Michigan is held in trust by the state for use by all residents and is not privately owned.

A private security officer speaks with Vicki Apatoff, left, and Mary Garrison, right, along the beach in front of Justin Ishbia lakefront property in Winnetka on Wednesday, July 19, 2023. The security guard believed the women were trespassing and called 911, however Winnetka police have informed residents they are legally allowed on the beach.

When police are called, residents have been assured they are within their rights to travel along the beach as long as their feet are in the water and they don’t venture on to private property.

Mary Garrison, a former Winnetka Park District commissioner, right, sits on a seawall and chats with Winnetka police officers while watching construction on Justin Ishbia lakefront property in Winnetka on July 19, 2023. Since construction started earlier this summer, nearly all of the trees have been removed and the bluff has been taken down. The property was once home to three separate homes and is now a 3.7-acre site.

Beyond the continued construction at the property, there is still unfinished business between Ishbia and the Winnetka Park District. A land swap signed in October 2020 would gift the land at 261 Sheridan Road, which Ishbia owns, to the Park District in an effort to combine Elder Lane and Centennial beaches. The Park District and Ishbia have both moved forward with separate construction plans but the Park Board has expressed hope that the two can work together to minimize the amount of construction needed to keep both public and private land preserved.

See also  More Explores: Pineapple Picasso - ABC7 Southwest Florida



Source link

Latest articles

Boyfriend’s workaholism creates relationship tension

Dear Eric: I’m 51 years old. I’ve been dating “John” for two and...

What does Donald Trump's return mean for Canada?

In today’s The Big Story podcast, in the end, it wasn’t even particularly...

See the Cover of ‘Holes’ Author Louis Sachar’s First Adult Novel (Exclusive)

If you grew up loving books like Holes and Sideways Stories from...

Fennel and Celery Salad with Roth Buttermilk Blue Recipe

InstructionsStep 1 Halve and thinly slice the fennel bulb, then transfer to a...

More like this

Boyfriend’s workaholism creates relationship tension

Dear Eric: I’m 51 years old. I’ve been dating “John” for two and...

What does Donald Trump's return mean for Canada?

In today’s The Big Story podcast, in the end, it wasn’t even particularly...

See the Cover of ‘Holes’ Author Louis Sachar’s First Adult Novel (Exclusive)

If you grew up loving books like Holes and Sideways Stories from...