Guilty on Both Counts: Retrial Jury Convicts Ex-Uber Driver of Setting the Fire That Became the Palisades Fire
Five months after a 10-2 deadlock, a federal jury found Jonathan Rinderknecht set the New Year's Day Lachman Fire that prosecutors say reignited as L.A.'s most destructive wildfire. He faces five to 40 years at sentencing March 17; his lawyer plans an appeal.

LOS ANGELES — Twenty-two months after the Palisades Fire tore through the Santa Monica Mountains, a federal jury has decided who started it. On Friday, jurors in downtown Los Angeles convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, a 30-year-old former Uber driver, of setting the New Year's Day brush fire that prosecutors say smoldered underground for nearly a week and then blew up into the most destructive wildfire in the city's history.
The verdict ended a retrial that began with jury selection on Nov. 2, NBC News reported. After just over two days of deliberations, jurors returned guilty verdicts on both counts, destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce, according to the Los Angeles Times. Rinderknecht's eyebrows shot up as the verdict was read, the Times reported; he then hugged his defense team.
U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang set sentencing for March 17. Prosecutors say Rinderknecht faces at least five years and as many as 40 years in federal prison.
A Second Jury, a Narrower Case
The first trial ended in a mistrial in June, when jurors deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal. Prosecutors then got a revised indictment, as the Herald reported when the retrial opened. They dropped a charge of setting timber afire and limited the destruction-of-property count to the smaller Lachman Fire, which sensors detected at 12:12 a.m. on Jan. 1, 2025. The arson count still covered both the Lachman Fire and the Palisades Fire, ABC News reported.
Firefighters put out the Lachman Fire after it burned roughly five to eight acres of brush. Prosecutors said it kept burning in root systems, and on Jan. 7 the Santa Ana winds fanned it back to life. The Palisades Fire went on to burn 23,448 acres, kill 12 people and destroy 6,837 homes, businesses and other structures, according to Los Angeles Fire Department figures cited by NBC News. It was not fully contained until Jan. 31, 2025.
First Assistant U.S. Atty. Bill Essayli told the Times the charges were narrowed for jurors who might balk at blaming one man for the whole disaster. "We had to take another shot at trying this, because of the weight of the evidence," he said. "There's no way we're going to let this guy walk out of the courtroom knowing he started the Palisades fire."
What Swayed the Jury
Prosecutors said Rinderknecht was angry and alone that New Year's Eve. After dropping off a passenger in Pacific Palisades, they said, he went to the Skull Rock Trailhead in Topanga State Park and set the fire. Geolocation data from his phone carrier placed him in a clearing about 30 feet from the flames as they spread, even though he later told investigators he had been near the bottom of the trail, ABC News reported, citing the U.S. Attorney's Office. Prosecutors also cited surveillance video of his car, a green Bic barbecue lighter carrying his DNA, and a question he asked ChatGPT about fault for a cigarette-caused wildfire, NBC News reported.
The defense argued that no one saw Rinderknecht start a fire and that no camera recorded the ignition. Defense attorney Steve Haney noted the lighter was found in Rinderknecht's rental car, not at the scene, and offered fireworks as an alternative cause.
A juror who gave only his first name, Cameron, told reporters he had been the lone vote for acquittal when deliberations began. The evidence that weighed most with him, he said, was Rinderknecht's own statement to investigators that he "didn't smell a fire, didn't see fireworks" on the hill. "Everything kind of started to point towards one conclusion," he told the Times.
Reaction, and the Questions That Remain
"We are disappointed in the verdict, but respect the jury process," Haney said, according to the Times. He said the defense plans to appeal.
Mayor Karen Bass, who lost her reelection bid this month, said in a statement that "no verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain families have endured," the BBC reported. "So many are still struggling to rebuild," she said. Councilmember Traci Park, who represents the Palisades, told NBC Los Angeles that "there is no amount of courtroom justice that will ever undo the harm that was caused."
The conviction does not settle every question about the fire. In a separate civil suit against the city and state, firefighters have testified that a series of communication failures and decisions by commanders led crews to leave the burn area too soon, according to the Times. Essayli said the verdict does not "exonerate the city or any other actors" for how they responded. "Both things can be true," he said. "You can have an arsonist and you can have a less than adequate response by the fire department."
More LA News

L.A. switches on first speed cameras in citywide crackdown on fast drivers

$22 million in state money headed to the Sepulveda Basin

LAPD Can Put Plate-Reading Cameras on Valley Streetlights After Council Veto Falls One Vote Short

L.A. Will Pick Who Gets Its Homeless Housing Under New Deal With the County

