Monday, October 26, 2026Los Angeles, CA · Writer login
Business

Metro Eyes Sherman Oaks' Fashion Square Parking Lot for a Subway Rail Yard, and the Mall's Operator Says It Was Never Asked

A Sepulveda subway maintenance yard could land on Westfield's lot or The Plant shopping center in Panorama City. Neighbors are furious, Westfield says it was blindsided, and the mayor-elect wants Metro to weigh the cost to business.

By Herald Staff ·
An elevated view over a Los Angeles Metro rail yard on a hazy day: parallel tracks curve toward a long white maintenance building, with parked subway cars, shipping containers, stacked supplies and orange safety fencing in the foreground and the downtown Los Angeles skyline rising in the distance under a pale blue sky.
Metro's Division 20 rail yard near downtown Los Angeles, where B and D Line subway trains are stored and serviced, in October 2025. The Sepulveda Transit Corridor subway would need a similar yard in the San Fernando Valley, and Westfield Fashion Square's parking lot is one of five sites Metro has floated. Photo: SaarPro / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (license).

SHERMAN OAKS — One of the San Fernando Valley's best-known shopping centers has landed on a short list it never asked to be on. Los Angeles Metro is weighing the parking lot of Westfield Fashion Square on Riverside Drive as one of five possible sites for a rail maintenance and storage yard for its planned Sepulveda Transit Corridor subway, and the mall's operator says it heard about the idea at the same time the public did.

A Westfield spokesperson told NBC Los Angeles on Tuesday that the company had not spoken with Metro before Monday night's public presentations, which named the mall's lot as a candidate site.

A Rail Yard in Search of Land

The Sepulveda line is meant to fill one of the most congested gaps in the county's transit map: the north-south crossing of the Santa Monica Mountains between the Valley and the Westside. In January, Metro's board picked an underground heavy-rail route running from the Van Nuys Metrolink station to the E Line's Expo/Sepulveda station, with a link to the G Line and the planned East San Fernando Valley light rail line at Van Nuys Boulevard. The board also identified a first phase of about 8.4 miles between Wilshire/Westwood and the G Line's Van Nuys station.

Trains need somewhere to sleep and be serviced, and that takes a lot of flat land. According to a Metro presentation shared by the Sherman Oaks Homeowners Association and posted by the Greater Valley Glen Council, the five options are:

  • The existing Westfield Fashion Square on Riverside Drive
  • Along Oxnard Street between Kester Avenue and Sepulveda Boulevard
  • Metro's existing parking and nearby properties near the G Line Van Nuys station
  • North of Victory Boulevard, just west of Van Nuys Boulevard
  • The Plant shopping center and nearby properties east of Van Nuys Boulevard

Two of the five sites are working retail centers. NBC Los Angeles reported that The Plant, in Panorama City, includes properties occupied by businesses such as In-N-Out, Chipotle and PetSmart.

Metro said it picked out the mall because of its layout. "The Westfield site was identified because a large part of that site is parking lots and because it is nestled next to the freeway," the agency said in a statement to CBS Los Angeles. Metro added that it had only named the mall as a possible site and had not drawn up any designs.

A Shouting Match in Sherman Oaks

Monday's scoping meeting at the Sherman Oaks East Valley Adult Center on Van Nuys Boulevard did not go as planned. Hundreds of residents packed the room, and Metro had to switch speakers several times because of shouting and interruptions, CBS Los Angeles reported. "They could have taken questions, but they didn't, and people were very frustrated," resident Betty Carmona told the station.

Some speakers worried the mall itself could be torn down or sold. Others told NBC Los Angeles they feared noise, traffic and a hit to the shopping experience. "I'm not happy about the parking disappearing because what I'm afraid of is that there will be trains being repaired across the street from where we live," said Ken Phillips, who attended the meeting.

Matt Epstein of the Sherman Oaks Homeowners Association argued that Metro has better choices. "There's vacant properties all over Oxnard, Victory (boulevards). There's city owned properties; there's county-owned properties," he told NBC Los Angeles. "For them to come into a residential neighborhood is absolutely crazy."

The Business Question at City Hall

The fight also puts the cost of losing working commercial land on the table, and the area's incoming mayor has raised it. Mayor-elect Nithya Raman, whose City Council district includes Sherman Oaks, called the site choice a "difficult decision" in a statement and said Metro "should also ensure it is properly weighing the costs of removing productive commercial and industrial locations in its full evaluation." As mayor, Raman is likely to chair the Metro board, which rotates its chair and includes a representative from the city of Los Angeles, NBC Los Angeles noted.

County Supervisor Lindsey Horvath, who sits on the Metro board and represents Sherman Oaks, struck a similar note. "The question should not simply be where Metro can fit a maintenance facility, but how Metro can meet its operational requirements while making the most responsible and beneficial use of public and private land," she said.

What Comes Next

Nothing has been decided. The meetings are part of a scoping period run by the Federal Transit Administration and Metro before the agency prepares a federal environmental document and a recirculated draft environmental impact report under state law. Metro says comments are due Nov. 23 and can be sent online, by email to sepulvedatransit@metro.net, by phone at 213-922-7375 or by mail.

The agency told NBC Los Angeles it is still a long way from a final choice, with more meetings planned for spring. Construction on the line isn't expected to start for several more years. For the businesses in Sherman Oaks and Panorama City that now find their parking lots on a transit map, that is a long time to wait for an answer.

Original reporting by The Los Angeles Herald, drawing on NBC Los Angeles, CBS Los Angeles, Los Angeles Metro and the Greater Valley Glen Council, as linked above.

More Business